Waldorf Schools

So I have been exploring different preschool options for my sensory disordered son =)  Here’s the related information:

He’s smart, saavy, creative, verbal, emotionally intelligent and aware of his own needs.  He’s charming and silly, imaginative and obedient (when things are going well).  BUT… he is sensory sensitive, moody, motor delayed, shy, and shuts down quickly when he doesn’t like what’s going on.  (i.e. Tantrum!).  He’s going to be four in a month and has never been good in a group, except for his own siblings and the church nursery.  He is afraid of authority and challenge, and tends to be introspective instead of engaging in a group or direct instruction.  He’d rather sit out from Life =)

So I requested some information from a local Waldorf school, which I knew to be untraditional and encouraging of creativity, and here’s what I found out.

Waldorf schools are guided by a philosophy that encourages emotional and physical learning, along with the intellectual stuff they teach—“whole child” education, they call it.  In fact, they seem to downplay cognitive or academic skills, although I’m sure they would argue otherwise.  I think they believe in trying to get the child to want to learn on their own instead of providing them lots of early instruction… so they encourage reading/writing between grades 1 and 3 instead of preK-1.  During the early years, they just want to foster an imaginative environment, love of learning, and basic self-discipline skills.  Language arts is mainly for fun.  Math seems to go slower and has more of a philosophical bent instead of drilling lots of operations; they combine multiplication and division with addition and subtraction from the beginning.

There’s a heavy emphasis on nature, folklore, and arts.  They try to balance right- and left-brained activities, so they do a lot of gym, foreign language, visual art, dance, and music (i.e. singing, recorder, etc).  They also do eurhythmics—a fancy way of saying rhythmic gymnastics which tries to combine music with movement so the ear, eye, mind, and body work together in gaining a music education.  And a typical Waldorf school will be proud of the science and nature activities they weave into the curriculum: nature walks, zoo trips, garden projects, seed experiments, community experiences, etc.  They want to foster an intrinsic love of nature and action in a child, so they try to get them out of the classroom or at least make it less artificial.

Other untraditional things include assigning children a class and teacher that they stay with throughout their time at the school: teachers and students stay together, grow together like a family, and are forced to find ways of relating since they can’t get rid of each other!  I don’t know, but I think this would be one of the most challenging rules… as both teacher and student!  And also I worry that this would be a little restrictive since reflecting on my own education tells me that changing teachers and friends was insecuring at times but prepared me for life… learning to adapt to different people and their rules, make new friends, etc.  I am sure, however, that there are benefits to not having this added adjustment, especially for sensitive children.

They also don’t give grades.

So what are we to make of this interesting philosophy?

While I don’t endorse the roots of Waldorf belief, my gut feeling is that it is very similar to a classical homeschooling experience like Charlotte Mason.  Obviously it is a secular school, so they aren’t going to teach Christianity.  But the overall experience from the child’s perspective is probably a lot like homeschool: hands-on activities, relationship with teacher and students (that is unchanging!), individual attention, no grades, moving at one’s own pace, stimulating love of learning, slower or less rigorous drill and rote work, time for field trips and unstructured learning time, permits creative learning/assignments, integrates special talents into the school day (i.e. dance, music, etc).

Waldorf schooling is sometimes seen as an elite route because it is expensive and comes from higher German philosophy… read about Rudolf Steiner if you want more info.  But Waldorf values are evidently seen in public preschools and kindergartens (i.e. “Kindergarten” comes from similar higher German philosophy), and so the question for Americans today is probably not IF they subscribe to Waldorf values, but for HOW LONG they do… eventually most parents trade the organic, humanistic, childlikeness of preschool for the rigors of higher academic education (including sitting for long hours at desks, reading long textbooks, and listening to lectures).  This is just the way of secondary education, and honestly, most adult jobs.  So the question is when you want your children to make that switch.  When they’re ready?  When they hit puberty?  When they are 3rd grade?  1st?

And another related question is, when should rigorous academic instruction take priority over intrinsic, child-directed learning?  Some children, especially more artistic or sensitive ones, may do well with the instrinsic motivation model until they graduate.  But others may really need more formal, extrinsic motivation that traditional models provide.  Plus, many early childhood experts agree that children should be encouraged to read, write, compute, and use computers as soon as they are developmentally able… not after their imagination or intrinsic love of learning has taken root.  Some children are never motivated intrinsically!  Or are motivated too late for their academic skills to take root firmly.  In other words, it is a chicken-and-egg phenomenon: both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation should work together, not push the other out.

In conclusion, I found the Waldorf school philosophy interesting and not as offensive as I once thought it was, when I was an Education student.  At the time, it seemed too loose and academically lite.  But now that I have a sensitive, artistic, and imaginative child, I see it has its niche.  And it is not altogether out of the mainstream when I consider the philosophy of the toddler, preschool, and kindergarten years which seem to produce a lot of fruit for a child.

So chieck it out if you think your child fits the bill.  It was a pleasant surprise.

3 thoughts on “Waldorf Schools

  1. I was reading your blog as I sifted through blogs today, I remember a time when I had 3 that were 4 and under… there we days when I didn’t know what on earth I was thinking! Enjoy it, they grow so fast. My older set are now 7, neraly 9, and 11 – time flies. My oldest is about to lose his last tooth!

    I wanted to invite you to learn more about Waldorf from the home educating stand point. I moderate a group that has hundreds of moms from all over the world and all sized families supporting each other on this journey.

    Melisa Nielsen
    http://www.alittlegardenflower.com

  2. Children are our greatest and most precious assets. Children can begin a journey to success only when their parents commit to. Goal setting is a way for parents to help their child achieve success in all ways..

  3. Dealing with sensory impaired children is hard work especially wondering how will they fit into a structured classroom surrounded by other children, and wondering when will their next meltdown happen and learning what triggers them. I hope you have found the help you needed. my youngest started private occupational therapy for two years and speech for three at age 2 in a half till age 5. I had to keep him away from other children for alomst a year because his melt downs would physically hurt other children. He had no sense of touch and could not control his agresssive touch because he could not feel it. Through proper treatment, I was advised to get him invovled in sensory toddler controlled playgroups. The first few were very difficult, but it turned into a positive experience in the end. He went to 2 years of a co-op preschool, two days a week at a day care just to teach him how to cope with himeself away from me, and then finally kindergarten this year. He has learned a lot about himself, how to control himself,and when to come to me and actually admit he is having a bad day and wants his rub down therapy. His issues are so minor now, that when people meet him, they would never even notice that their was a problem with him. His biggest thing is that he still does have a hard time keeping his hands to himself, and he is still aggressive, but it has not enterferred with school. All his therapy has actually increased his intellegence and is very advanced for his age. Good luck with your child, they sure are worth all the work!!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s